ALIAS: Good Enough – 1 Samuel 15 (Sermon Notes)
Do you want to know what breaks the heart of God? There are three stories that reveal God’s broken heart so very clearly…
- Jeremiah 42:10: God is broken when he see a nation in brokenness from the consequences of their sin.
- 2 Samuel 24:10-25: God is distraught up when David’s sin causes a nation to suffer.
- Genesis 6:5-7: God is broken when sin ruins the world and all of humanity except one family.
This same brokenness God has over the sins of the masses is experienced when one person breaks faith. 1 Samuel 15:35 tells us Saul’s sin leads God to regret.
Sin starts with a compromise. (1 Samuel 15:7-9)
- God’s mission is clear. (1 Samuel 15:1-3) God has here commanded total destruction of the Amalekites. This goes back to Exodus 17:8-16 when the Amalekites attacked the Israelites as they were passing into the promised land led by Moses.
- I suppose we don’t know all the reasons why God has commanded the destruction of the Amalekites. But we know, God has put them under the “ban” this word is used on nations that were to be driven out completely.
- We must realize that this will not happen again, God speaks to no nation the way that he spoke to Israel. No country has the right or mandate to wipe out another people group. So, while we might not understand it – we can accept this as a divine commandment and even exception that comes straight from the Lord.
- These nations were known for destroying their own children in detestable idolatrous practices, something God abhors. God commands total destruction so no taint of their sin would remain. In Joshua 23:11-13 Joshua reminds Israel that they must drive out the idolatrous nations before them or they would be ensnared by their idolatry and would fall. This is eventually what would happen, but it took almost 1,000 years from Joshua to the deportation and captivity. Talk about a slow fade. When we deviate from God’s mission just a little bit we will eventually end up falling to our sin – it might just take some time.
- How do you defeat sin and temptation? Completely – there is no half-way to righteousness. What is it that you’ve let have a foot hold in your life? Maybe you’ve eliminated everything but just one corner, maybe you tossed out all temptation except that one, maybe you’ve forgiven everybody but them… What is it that you hang on to?
Compromise leads brokenness. (1 Samuel 15:10-11)
- The brokenness that takes place is in us, but also in the very heart of God.
- Saul sees the choice sheep and cattle. He values the possessions, not the people. They keep for themselves what is under the ban. Just like at Jericho God dedicated some things to himself or to destruction.
- Saul compromises and kills the people, but keeps the goods. Spares the king, possibly as a trophy.
- In 1 Samuel 15:13, we see that he apparently believes he has done God’s will! It started with a compromise and once he crossed that line it became all too easy.
- God regrets that he has made Saul king. Does God have regrets for you?
- Does he regret making you successful?
- Does he regret giving you a family?
- Does he regret giving you a place of leadership?
Repentance, not excuses bring wholeness. (1 Samuel 15:13-21)
- At first, Saul celebrates his sin. If Saul had any modesty shown by hiding during his coronation it is gone now as her erects monuments to his greatness. He celebrates his failure. We celebrate our failure.
- We erect billboards and celebrate our sin and brokenness. While God just watches and weeps at the sight of our sin.
- When he’s caught, Saul blames the people for keeping the livestock. Samuel calls Saul actions “the sin of rebellion”(1 Samuel 15:23), he equates that sin with divination. The word for rebellion means to “press your case” we might say, “press your luck.”
- Saul claims to know what God really wants and is for the people to keep their possessions. I think of Jesus’ words in Matthew 7:23 to other people who claimed they knew him, “I never knew you, go away from me.” It’s obvious they never knew Christ.
- Saul even tries to say that the reason he sinned was for God’s benefit. Samuel quickly reminds Saul that he would rather have obedience than excuses or even repentance. This is what Paul reminds us of in Romans 6:1, “Should we continue to sin in order that grace may abound?” Absolutely not.
- What will you offer? Excuses or repentance. Proverbs 28:13, “No one who conceals transgressions will prosper, but one who confesses and forsakes them will obtain mercy.”
1 John 1:8-9, “8 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. 9 If we confess our sins, he who is faithful and just will forgive us our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness.”
Do you want to know what breaks the heart of God? There are three stories that reveal God’s broken heart so very clearly…
· Jeremiah 42:10: God is broken when he see a nation in brokenness from the consequences of their sin.
· 2 Samuel 24:10-25: God is distraught up when David’s sin causes a nation to suffer.
· Genesis 6:5-7: God is broken when sin ruins the world and all of humanity except one family.
This same brokenness God has over the sins of the masses is experienced when one person breaks faith. 1 Samuel 15:35 tells us Saul’s sin leads God to regret.
1. Sin starts with a compromise. (1 Samuel 15:7-9)
a. God’s mission is clear. (1 Samuel 15:1-3) God has here commanded total destruction of the Amalekites. This goes back to Exodus 17:8-16 when the Amalekites attacked the Israelites as they were passing into the promised land led by Moses.
i. I suppose we don’t know all the reasons why God has commanded the destruction of the Amalekites. But we know, God has put them under the “ban” this word is used on nations that were to be driven out completely.
ii. We must realize that this will not happen again, God speaks to no nation the way that he spoke to Israel. No country has the right or mandate to wipe out another people group. So, while we might not understand it – we can accept this as a divine commandment and even exception that comes straight from the Lord.
iii. These nations were known for destroying their own children in detestable idolatrous practices, something God abhors.
b. God commands total destruction so no taint of their sin would remain. In Joshua 23:11-13 Joshua reminds Israel that they must drive out the idolatrous nations before them or they would be ensnared by their idolatry and would fall.
i. This is eventually what would happen, but it took almost 1,000 years from Joshua to the deportation and captivity. Talk about a slow fade!
ii. When we deviate from God’s mission just a little bit we will eventually end up falling to our sin – it might just take some time.
c. How do you defeat sin and temptation? Completely – there is no half-way to righteousness. What is it that you’ve let have a foot hold in your life? Maybe you’ve eliminated everything but just one corner, maybe you tossed out all temptation except that one, maybe you’ve forgiven everybody but them… What is it that you hang on to?
2. Compromise leads brokenness. (1 Samuel 15:10-11)
a. The brokenness that takes place is in us, but also in the very heart of God.
b. Saul sees the choice sheep and cattle. He values the possessions, not the people. They keep for themselves what is under the ban. Just like at Jericho God dedicated some things to himself or to destruction.
i. Saul compromises and kills the people, but keeps the goods. Spares the king, possibly as a trophy.
ii. In 1 Samuel 15:13, we see that he apparently believes he has done God’s will! It started with a compromise and once he crossed that line it became all too easy.
c. God regrets that he has made Saul king. Does God have regrets for you?
i. Does he regret making you successful?
ii. Does he regret giving you a family?
iii. Does he regret giving you a place of leadership?
3. Repentance, not excuses bring wholeness. (1 Samuel 15:13-21)
a. At first, Saul celebrates his sin.
i. If Saul had any modesty shown by hiding during his coronation it is gone now as her erects monuments to his greatness. He celebrates his failure. We celebrate our failure.
ii. We erect billboards and celebrate our sin and brokenness. While God just watches and weeps at the sight of our sin.
b. When he’s caught, Saul blames the people for keeping the livestock. Samuel calls Saul actions “the sin of rebellion”(1 Samuel 15:23), he equates that sin with divination. The word for rebellion means to “press your case” we might say, “press your luck.”
i. Saul claims to know what God really wants and is for the people to keep their possessions. I think of Jesus’ words in Matthew 7:23 to other people who claimed they knew him, “I never knew you, go away from me.” It’s obvious they never knew Christ.
ii. Saul even tries to say that the reason he sinned was for God’s benefit. Samuel quickly reminds Saul that he would rather have obedience than excuses or even repentance. This is what Paul reminds us of in Romans 6:1, “Should we continue to sin in order that grace may abound?” Absolutely not.
c. What will you offer? Excuses or repentance. Proverbs 28:13, “No one who conceals transgressions will prosper, but one who confesses and forsakes them will obtain mercy.”
1 John 1:8-9, “8 If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us. 9 If we confess our sins, he who is faithful and just will forgive us our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness.”

